Badges for Librarians

Submitted by Rebekah Wallin on Fri, 08/03/2012 - 11:51am.
Rebekah Wallin's picture

This spring the Young Adult Library Services Association (better know as YALSA) received funding to develop a virtual badge program for professional development (ht Janice). A grant for this project is provided by three big badging proponents: HASTAC, the Mozilla Foundation, and the MacArthur Foundation.

The goal is to provide badges for librarians and library staff as they gain skills needed to meet the needs of 21st century teens, as described by YALSA's Competencies for Serving Youth in Libraries. A writer on the YALSA blog explains the idea behind this innovative approach to continuing education:

We are all aware that because of the rapidly changing nature of how information is created and delivered, librarians must constantly learn new skills to be effective in our daily work. In addition, we know that in today’s world, learning happens everywhere, and YALSA wants to help librarians and library workers get recognition for the skills they are acquiring outside traditional settings.

Librarians love lifelong learning more than any other profession I know. While earning badges may or may not offer any intrinsic motivation for continuing education, virtual badges certainly would provide librarians with recognition for learning new skills. I can already imagine the future of our resumes, Facebook (& co.) profiles, blogs, and other virtual spaces, tricked out with cool badges representing our learning. It's definitely going to be colorful.

Of course, the usual question comes to mind: Does this actually contribute anything to the future of learning? And I find myself skeptical. Badging seems like a good system for giving learners something to show for their continuing education, it's just hard to see what it will change about the way people already learn. Young adult librarians have been learning for a long time. It seems silly to pay too much attention to the badges themselves. The heart of continuing learning experiences should be on creating excellent educational content and providing real opportunities for learners to apply new skills.

Many thoughtful people who are much smarter than me have spent a long time discussing badging, and it's complicated to balance these opposing perspectives. In the end, I think any innovative idea is certainly worth exploring, and we won't really be able to predict the impact until it happens. In the meantime, for better or worse, I think we'll probably start adapting to the badging ecosystem without even realizing it.

One final thought: I think that badging could be a cool way for librarians to showcase their skills to library users, especially to teens. From my limited exposure to the conversation, it seems like there is too much focus put on the role of badging to find employment, rather than as a functional way to share knowledge at the workplace. What if the library website had a page of the collected badges of all staff? Teens could click on a badge (e.g. creating a website, video editing, writing poetry, etc.) to contact the person who can help them with their question. Maybe we'll even make analog badges to wear around the library.



Janice Joo's picture
Janice Joo Says:
Mon, 08/06/2012 - 9:28am

Hi Rebekah!

I'm so glad you wrote about this! I was particularly intrigued about your perspective on how badges could be used by young library users to find the best librarian for them (instead of as a credentialing system for hiring). I think that's quite a shift in badge thinking! ... Badges as meta data about the employee!

Perhaps EdLab could try this out. All EdLab employees could come up with badges to describe each of our skills. It could be an interesting way to embellish and personalize our bio pages. With this, I'm curious what would happen to the collaboration dynamic within EdLab AND whether it will improve how external parties find EdLab staff.

Again, great thought-provoking post Rebekah!


Kate Meersschaert's picture
Kate Meersschaert Says:
Mon, 08/06/2012 - 9:31am

Janice, I have often wondered this! Whether we could integrate gamified badging into the EdLab dashboard? Blog? Most comments on Vialogues gets you the "Comment Commando" badge etc.... Hmmm I am excited to hear what everyone thinks of this! I wonder how it could be intergrated into NLT or whether badging is better for internal motivation/user behavior. It has worked-well for GitHub!

I second Janice's "great post" thoughts Rebekah!


Rebekah Wallin's picture
Rebekah Wallin Says:
Mon, 08/06/2012 - 9:48am

Kate, I'm pretty sure you've already earned the Comment Commando badge for Vialogues.

Comment Commando badge


Rebekah Wallin's picture
Rebekah Wallin Says:
Mon, 08/06/2012 - 9:48am

(Here's your badge.)


Janice Joo's picture
Janice Joo Says:
Mon, 08/06/2012 - 11:21am

lol! i agree kate deserves that badge. love it!


Sharon Hsiao's picture
Sharon Hsiao Says:
Fri, 08/03/2012 - 12:16pm

yeh. i like the idea of wearing real badges. it reminds me those waitresses in TGI Fridays :p

In fact, HASTAC and digital media has this CFP
A DIGITAL MEDIA AND LEARNING RESEARCH COMPETITION ON BADGING AND BADGE SYSTEMS DEVELOPMENT" Looks fun. There are several useful research questions for further advancement in badges research.