Independent Music Learning

Submitted by Haymar Lim on Mon, 07/30/2012 - 6:38am.
Haymar Lim's picture

Last Friday I received my first check from Teachers College and I jovially dashed to get something nice for myself as a reward. After some browsing online, I headed to Guitar Center and ended up buying a nice little acoustic-electric guitar, as I had been meaning to for quite a while. I had no experience playing guitar, so, like many of my friends, I headed onto YouTube and Google to learn.

Lu wrote a blog mentioning the strengths of musical communities and their educational potential a few months back. The tools for independent musical education are out there. There are countless tutorial videos online giving advice. The best ones gain popularity and become easier to find. Many forums exist where a community is ready to answer any questions that haven't been answered already. People learning to play guitar often have friends who now how to play. I personally asked some of my friends for some pointers and for good videos. Of course the experience isn't as refined and smooth as a private music lesson from a good teacher, but as it is now, a person could learn how to play the guitar without a teacher, and that is a powerful thing. If the community could create an environment where independent study is possible with just basic video, images and text, imagine what could be done with more sophisticated tools? For example, Vialogues could be used at specific points in a tutorial and clarification could be made. There are countless possibilities for streamlining the educational experience. What do you think? Should this be a model for online learning?



Duncan Asiedu's picture
Duncan Asiedu Says:
Wed, 08/01/2012 - 8:19pm

Certainly it could be a model for online learning. It's a common practice nowadays for aspiring musical instrument learners to recieve one on one lessons from online video chat mediums like Skype.


Josh Lopez's picture
Josh Lopez Says:
Tue, 07/31/2012 - 9:21am

One concept that does seems important, though not necessarily required, for successful independent learning is gamefication. Would you rather sit and practice scales and finger positions, or play a game that teaches them to you? It seems to me that the hardest part of independent learning is finding enough cause to stay with the task.


Mingoro Fanny's picture
Mingoro Fanny Says:
Mon, 07/30/2012 - 10:34pm

Hey in addition to what you have said i believe that this concept also can be used for many other aspects. For example i play soccer and if i'm not on the field practicing I'm home on YouTube or Google learning new things. Vialogues can be a great instrument or tool to help one with independent study.


Oumar Soumahoro's picture
Oumar Soumahoro Says:
Mon, 08/06/2012 - 12:27am

I agree with you Mingoro. As we getting our outside friends to participate in the video we post on vialogue, I think posting video up about our hobby will be helpful for other people to learn outside of things they like and be more active in their lives.


Rebecca Hyams's picture
Rebecca Hyams Says:
Mon, 07/30/2012 - 9:40am

This has been somewhat of a hot topic in the music community. If you're interested, there was a discussion about it back in 2010 (I didn't realize it was from that long ago until I went to the archives) on Soundcheck. They reached similar conclusions to yours from what I remember.

Basically, for basic instruction (learning how to play popular music on your guitar for example) video lessons are fine. For more advanced types of lessons (let's say you decide to take up classical guitar and study technique) online learning will always be lacking (because sound/tone will never sound quite the same as it does live through speakers and with fixed cameras it's easy to miss things like finger positions)


Kate Meersschaert's picture
Kate Meersschaert Says:
Mon, 07/30/2012 - 8:55am

Haymar, this is a great example of "self-credentialing!" and scaffolding learning outside of traditional sources (i.e. schools). I am excited to learn more about our progress learning and exploring Vialogues as a self-teaching tool! Here is an example we created when we explored using Vialogues for language acquisition.