Research Digest: Do career/technical courses prevent at-risk students from dropping out of high school?

Submitted by Greg Schrank on Tue, 06/05/2012 - 5:33pm.
Greg Schrank's picture

Plank, Stephen B. (2008). High School Dropout and the Role of Career and Technical Education: A Survival Analysis of Surviving High School. Sociology of Education, 81, 345-370.

Research has suggested a number of factors, at both the personal and institutional level, as to why students drop out of school. As the authors state, dropping out is the "culmination of disengagement" from school. Educators and researchers tend to focus on the process leading up to a student's decision to drop out rather than the act of dropping out itself. This study seeks to determine the role career and technical education (CTE) courses play in at-risks students' success or failure in school.

CTE courses, traditionally referred to as vocational learning, historically suffered from non-rigorous curriculums and lack of skills beyond entry level jobs. In the mid to late 90's an effort was made to improve CTE courses in hopes of making those students who took these courses more employable as well as diminish the negative stigma attached to vocational education. As a result, CTE courses have been designed to tie in traditional academic goals with more practical applications. The idea is to "forge...emotional and cognitive connections" with the curriculum, thus increasing motivation and ultimately academic success.

If you imagine a continuum with traditional academic courses at one extreme and CTE classes at the other, the authors believe a balance of both can lead to the greatest likelihood for academic success for students at risk of dropping out. Based on publicly available high school drop-out records, a 1:2 CTE to Core Academic courses ratio best suggests a student will succeed academically. The authors point to increased engagement and a greater understanding of how school will benefit a student in the workplace as reasons for this result.

A secondary focus of this study sought to determine if students older than their peers, a demographic that regularly suffers from higher dropout rates, would benefit from this same balance. Unfortunately, there was no correlation, suggesting that other factors contribute to this groups dropping out beyond changes in a curriculum.

EdLab Relevance
With all the recent concern over the need for a revitalized working class, there is definitely an opportunity to get a head start in developing courses that will engage and motivate students who are more likely to take CTE classes. This article doesn't really address HOW to make these classes more marketable/engaging/worthwhile to students, so it seems like research and/or an analysis of relevant literature would be the next step in ultimately coming up with a solution to this problem.

AttachmentSize
ResearchDigestLogo.jpg5.51 KB


Laura Costello's picture
Laura Costello Says:
Wed, 06/06/2012 - 9:10am

Super interesting, Greg! I wonder if there is a relationship between CTE courses and moving on to college? Does enrollment in vocational courses open up the possibility of forgoing college or give students confidence/grade advantages that lead them to stay longer in academia?


Rebecca Beck's picture
Rebecca Beck Says:
Wed, 06/06/2012 - 10:05am

I agree, this is such an interesting topic. I believe that vocational schools have a negative connotation in the U.S. but are well respected in some European and Asian countries such as Germany and Japan. I wonder if the changing economy will make Americans rethink how CTE courses are perceived and if the balance discussed is created how that will shape CTE courses moving forward.


Greg Schrank's picture
Greg Schrank Says:
Wed, 06/06/2012 - 10:18am

Indeed, the current state of the economy and the outsourcing of manufacturing jobs have highlighted the need and importance of a robust working class. It's great to be a world leader in tech, innovation, etc. but without a strong infrastructure its virtually unsustainable. Hopefully we'll see an ongoing shift in perceptions and attitudes towards CTE classes.

I remember our high school had a shop class where students would work on their cars and other vehicles, and those kids always seemed like they were in their element, even if they weren't engaged in their other classes as much. I agree that internal motivation is the biggest factor in a students eventual graduation or dropping out, so it will be interesting to see what future research finds re: how intrinsic motivation can be influenced by extrinsic factors.