Trends in Ed: Romney's Plan

Submitted by Fred Rossoff on Fri, 05/25/2012 - 4:39pm.
Fred Rossoff's picture

This week Mitt Romney released the plan for his prospective education policy, titled “A Chance for Every Child.” As the New York Time emphasizes in its reporting, there isn’t a great deal of daylight between elite policy prescriptions for education across the two main political parties. Both parties have a similarly apocalyptic view of the failures of our educational system, particularly when it comes to minority achievement, and both parties are working to reform teachers unions and increase charter schools and student choice.

Romney admittedly goes farther than Obama would in this direction with his proposal that poor and special needs students would be able to take their allotted schooling funds to any school they choose, including “digital courses”. The plan also pushes back on the federal drive towards accountability that has characterized education reform for the past decade (e.g. No Child Left Behind).

We are at a point at which the potential for educational services seems a great deal higher than what we’re currently getting, and although Romney’s plan, as one would expect, doesn’t allocate more funds for the education sector (and may take some away), a push towards experimentation on the demand side (if met by responsible and capable education providers) could be the kick in the butt our system needs.



Greg Schrank's picture
Greg Schrank Says:
Mon, 06/04/2012 - 4:05pm

As a Tom Ashbrook adherent, this post reminded me of an On Point episode he did recently where there was a good discussion on the pros and cons of Romney's plan.

Here's the audio:
http://soundcloud.com/onpointradio/education-and-mitt-romney

and the intro from NPR:

Mitt Romney was all economy all the time during most of the Republican primary season. Last week, he turned to education. Almost everyone agrees it is the key to the country’s future. But Romney declared that millions of American kids are getting “a third world education” in the USA.

His answer? More school choice. Let poor and disabled students take their federal funding and attend any school they like, even private school. If, that is, they can find such a school. And get in.

http://onpoint.wbur.org/2012/05/29/education-and-mitt-romney


Greg Schrank's picture
Greg Schrank Says:
Mon, 06/04/2012 - 4:07pm

And I forgot to add, I think its certainly an interesting plan, but I don't know that its practical to have a system where families can choose any school for their child. It seems that demand for some schools would be overwhelming, while other schools would likely see little or no demand.